In the dynamic landscape of South African entrepreneurship, choosing the right business structure is a critical decision that can significantly impact the success and sustainability of your new business venture. It is important to take the time to understand the options available to you before starting as it can be a bit of an admin nightmare and have possible tax consequences to change structures later on. It’s not impossible, but it is time consuming and expensive.

There are three main business structures prevalent in South Africa. The businesses that are the fastest to get off the ground are the ones that are not legal entities (sole proprietorship & partnerships). The legal entities are a bit more time consuming to get off the ground but have many benefits as well (private companies, public companies, non-profit organisations). We will delve deeper into three of these and should these three not meet your requirements, feel free to reach out to us at admin@axiaconsulting.co.za to set up a consultation and we can help you find the right solution.

1. Sole Proprietorship (non-legal entity):

A sole proprietorship is the simplest form of business ownership. With a sole proprietorship, a single individual owns and operates the business. This structure is often favoured by small enterprises or freelancers because to its ease of setup. The owner must include all income and expenses from the sole proprietorship in his/her income tax return at the end of the tax year and is responsible for payment of tax on such profits. 

The owner can trade under his/her name or open a linked business bank account to trade under a fictitious “company” name. This does not create a separate company, it is merely a way to look more professional when invoicing. The business bank account is directly linked to the owner’s personal bank account. It just makes it easier to separate business and personal income and expenses even though it is all essentially the owners.

Advantages

Disadvantages
  • Quick and easy to setup and start operating
  • The owner is legally liable for all the debts of the business as there is no separation between the business and the owner
  • The owner has complete control and makes all the decisions 
  • Limited access to capital. The owner can only raise capital in his/her personal capacity. This can make it difficult to run the business effectively from the start.
  • Minimal legal and administrative requirements
  • Limited skills. Until the business starts making enough money to be able to hire other people, the only skills available is that of the owner.
  • Owner receives all the profits
  • Not a legal entity
  • Easy to discontinue

Read more on the SARS website here.

2. Partnership (non-legal entity):

Partnerships involve two or more individuals sharing ownership and responsibility for a business. Each partner is taxed on his or her share of the partnership profits – sars.gov.za. Each person will bring something to the table, this could be in the form of monetary contributions, expertise, assets, etc and each will share in the profits and losses. 

There are three different types of partnerships:

General/ordinary partnership: partners are liable jointly for the debts or profits of a partnership;

Anonymous (sleeping) partnerships: the anonymous partner is not known to the public and is liable to the partners for pro rata share;

Commanditarian Partnership: the partner is purely a financial participant with a restricted liability-similar to a shareholder in a company. He shares in the profits and losses, but their liability is restricted to their specific contribution or to an agreed amount.

– sars.gov.za

Advantages

Disadvantages
  • Quick and easy to start and operate.
  • Unlimited personal liability for all partners
  • No statutory audit requirements
  • Potential for conflict between partners when making decisions
  • Shared responsibility and financial burden
  • Personal assets of all partners is at risk should the business come into financial difficulty
  • A combination of skills that can be applied to the business
  • The partnership dissolves and needs to be restarted each time a partner leaves or a new partner joins
  • Easier access to capital 
  • Not a legal entity
  • Easy to discontinue

3. Private Company (Pty) Ltd (separate legal entity):

A Private Company, denoted by “Pty Ltd,” is a separate legal entity from its owners and must be registered as a taxpayer. It offers limited liability, protecting the owner’s personal assets from business debts. This structure is suitable for medium to large enterprises. The private company is a completely separate entity and as such has certain rights, duties and responsibilities. The owner(s) of a private company are the shareholders. The people managing the company are the directors and may or may not be the same persons as the shareholders.

Advantages

Disadvantages
  • Limited liability for the shareholders. Personal assets of the shareholders are not linked to the business
  • More complex  administrative and legislative requirements
  • Higher credibility with clients and partners
  • More expensive to setup and operate
  • Ability to raise capital through share issuance
  • Requires some admin to discontinue business
  • The business continues uninterrupted if the shareholders change
  • Must register with CIPC and comply to the Companies Act
  • Easier to raise capital and funding
  • Heavy personal administrative and legislative burden on the directors
  • Can be run as a small, medium or large business
  • Easy to transfer ownership
  • Taxpayer in its own right
  • Shareholders don’t have to be involved in the day-to-day running but will share in the profits by way of dividends

Sars tax guide for small businesses

Choose wisely

For entrepreneurs seeking clarity on the ideal business structure in South Africa, understanding the nuances of each option is crucial. Whether you prioritise simplicity, liability protection, or access to capital, choosing the right structure will unquestionably align your business with its goals. As you navigate this decision, consult with legal and financial professionals for personalised guidance tailored to your unique circumstances. We would be happy to assist you with this as well as assisting with your finance and tax obligations for whichever business structure you decide on. Reach out to us on email at admin@axiaconsulting.co.za

If you are looking for a great local, financial and business related podcast, make sure to check out the Bizval podcast here.

Content created by Brand Narrative

Rochelle

Small business advice

Related Posts ...